03 January 2011 ~ 21 Comments

9 Membership Website & Continuity Income Business Models

The Awesomeness of Membership/Subscription Models

Izzy and I are working away at creating a Foolish membership site to teach you to have a successful online business.  Our first focus will be membership sites since Izzy has several successful membership sites that allowed him to quit his six figure corporate job and I’ve consulted on several membership sites (including Izzy’s) to make them more money.

We have a unique approach to online businesses that we summed up as Izzy’s 3 Product Approach (TM, copyright, patent-pending, etc :-) ).  We take a Content Creator approach to online business where we build an audience through a free, but awesome content series such as a podcast and then offer another awesome product for free in exchange for their email address.  Once the audience is growing, we offer an awesome product for sale.

And that’s just the beginning of it.

One thing I find a bit strange is all the confusion about membership sites or continuity business models.  I find it strange because we are completely surrounded in our daily lives with all sorts of continuity programs such as magazines, newspapers, cable TV, utilities, gyms, residential services (housekeeping, pest control, etc).

The list of membership and continuity services are almost endless.But maybe I should define a continuity program.  It is a subscription.  You buy and they deliver a product more than once.  To illustrate this, here are ways–off the top of my head, of different continuity models.

The 9 Different Membership Website and Continuity Income Models

The Freebie: You join a forum or email newsletter.  You didn’t pay anything, but a product is delivered to you weekly, monthly or you have continual access to content such as inside a forum.

The Charity: You agree to donate money to a charity and they deduct money from your account every month, quarter, year or whatever you agreed to.  You don’t get anything in exchange except for the good deed.

The Newspaper: You subscribe to a newspaper or other daily/weekly publication and they bill you multiple times per year such as weekly, monthly or annually.

The Magazine: You subscribe to a publication and pay an annual subscription fee.  Though you get the best deals if you subscribe for multiple years and pay up front.  There isn’t any continuity income on the part of the magazine because you aren’t auto-renewed each year.  They have to do some heavy marketing to get you to renew your subscription.  You get the continuity of having a magazine in the mail every month.

The eNewsletter: This is much like the Newspaper and there is even an off-line version called (you guessed it) The Newsletter.  This is a periodical on a specific topic (niche) such as investing where you get timely information that you pay either monthly, bi-annually or annually.  There most likely is an auto-renew component to your subscription.

The eCourse: Similar to the eNewsletter, but the scope is greatly reduced to a single topic and typically only a few months in duration.  This could be training on how to raise urban chickens or how to use a software or do email marketing–I think you get the picture.  This is also one of the easiest continuity programs to set up.  You need a sales page and an autoresponder such as Aweber.  All your content is delievered by email and you can take payment by Paypal.  This tends to work best as a one-time payment instead of a monthly subscription.  Can also be delivered by RSS.

The Online Course: A variation of the eCourse except this time the content is password protected on a website instead of delivered to the subscriber.  A simple way to do this is use the password protection built in to WordPress and the Read More tag.  Or you can use a membership management software to automate the whole thing.  This is very close to a Membership site.

The Publisher: This is similar to the Online Course and the Newsletter.  The subscribers get access to member-only periodical content.  IzzyVideo fits this model.  Izzy’s members get two premium videos per month and access to the extensive video library.  I would say most “membership” sites are the publisher model and it is a great model.  We teach this model, but will be adding the following one in our teaching too.

The Country Club: This is my definition of what a membership site really is–a country club.  I like to think of a membership site as a place the members can interact with each other and not just the content.  I love this model because it opens up the opportunity for user-generated premium content.  A lot of sites have user-generated content such as Digg.com or even Facebook, but most don’t have premium versions where the members are paying to get access to the content created by the other members.

The Country Club also improves the retention and stickiness of the membership site.  Retention being that they stay members and stickiness is how long they stay on the site.  Members get a ton of value being able to interact with like-minded people.  When you can share the ups and downs with someone else who understands, you’ll keep coming back.  Many times the content (typically the reason for paying) becomes a minor thing.

Except when joining a paid forum where the only content is user-generated content.  Oh, and there are a lot of these in the investing and tech worlds.  Anytime access to other experts as peers can greatly improve your own circumstances is reason enough to pay for access.  Industry associations offer this, too.

This is just an overview.  There are a bunch of different ways to tweak each one of these models and mix-and-match them.  Look at your niche or passion and think up ways you can use one or more of the above models for your online business.

~ t

  • Craig

    Inspired once again! Thanks Tim & Izzy!

  • Tom

    Tim I can’t tell you how perfect and timely this post is. I am just at the point where I want to approach a host for the videos I want to produce on the membership site I am planning. For a few days now I have been trying to write down an explanation of how this model works so I can ‘sell’ it to the guy I want to work for me. Your post along with diagram is perfect!!

    Thanks so much for all you do.

  • http://fitkidsonline.co Craig Strike

    This post couldn’t have come at a more perfect time for myself, as both of you know I am currently setting up a Membership Site. This has provided a little more clarity to the system that I will be implementing, but there is one question I have been meaning to ask in regards to a membership system.

    I will be looking at creating something along the lines of a “Publiser/Country Club” membership, where each month members are provided with new video and written content. I will also be providing my services as a personal trainer via email, skype, and hopefully webinars in the future, as well as implementing a members only forum for user generated content, some of which I hope to have featured as guest posts.

    My concern is, when a member signs up they have instant access to a back catalog of articles and videos that other members have had to pay for over the previous months. As you said with Izzy’s membership site, users then have access to “the extensive video library”.

    Is this fair to the other members who have paid for monthly for the previous content? And have either of you had any issues with this in the past?

    Also, I have just purchased Wishlist Member for WordPress, and have set up a test members site to better understand the product. It is FANTASTIC, and has many features to create different types of members sites such as sequential content delivery. I am very pleased with this plugin, and must say it is definitely worth the cost. I chose the Multi Site license as I am another 3 – 4 ideas for members sites I would like to develop in the future.

    Thanks again for what you’re doing, it is greatly appreciated. I look forward to your Foolish Members site, I have no doubt it will be full of quality content and ideas.

  • http://FoolishAdventure.com Tim Conley

    You can do like Izzy and charge for 6 months of access and then they can renew for another 6 months. Periodically, Izzy raises the price to account for the growing library. The other is to use sequential content delivery. I think this works best if your content will stop growing eventually. I think people will become frustrated at “never catching up” to where the new content is. However, it is possible to hide the content until it is time to give it to them and they’ll never know they are behind–assuming you don’t have any dated material.

  • http://FoolishAdventure.com Tim Conley

    Glad that helped Tom.

  • http://FoolishAdventure.com Tim Conley

    You’re welcome, Craig and stay inspired.

  • Tom

    This is a good question Craig and I guess it really depends on the content. If it is evergreen content then it will be hard to work out what to hide from new members so they are not over whelmed. I wonder if it’s useful to turn content into ‘paid-for’ packages after a certain time. So for example, you have a website which teaches you how to do a certain type of training programme. After all of the episodes have been published in the series, it could be turned into a packaged product which is more ‘complete’. This could then either be sold separately or part of a premium membership which includes ‘archived’ content.

    I’m probably not explaining myself very well.

  • KatieK.

    I like how you created simple applications to our everyday experiences. It opens my mind to what else I can offer. Thanks.

  • Daniel

    Tom, if you are interested in aMember/Wordpress setup for a membership site, I can help. I installed aMember to run my membership site and have had no issues.

    Good luck.

    And I echo the sentiments Izzy and Tim. LOVING your foolish advice.

    Daniel
    musicinthehall.com

  • Paulwa

    great info, i am working on a first product and your site has been useful. I am planning a 5 week course, with comments open for interaction with me (so not just info to consume on their own), drip fed weekly for 5 weeks, no new content beyond 5 weeks

    Don’t want to be tied to creating never ending content, but realise people need longer than 5 weeks to take action,

    Was thinking they get 5 weeks of training, 6 months (or could be 3?) access to the course info then are offered a further 6 months access after 6 months at a 50% of full charge.

    timewise i will still have to field questions for all that time as they’ll be able to access comments.

    or is it better to just say you get 3 months of access then bye bye so you reduce the interaction timespan

    it’s a $147 one off charge

    hope that’s clear

    any thoughts?

    paul

  • Anonymous

    Great info! Discovered my membership site is a combo of Publisher and Country Club. I’m interested in the monthly versus 6-month models. Why did Izzy decide on 6 months instead of monthly? I am sure it locks people in, but have you found that it discourages people from signing up?

  • http://www.bloggingbookshelf.com TristanH

    “A simple way to do this is use the password protection built in to WordPress and the Read More tag.”

    I know the tag, but I don’t know how you’d combine that with the password protection. As I’ve used and understood it, the password protection is for the whole post, regardless of where the more tag is or if it’s there or not. Have I missed something?

  • http://thesisready.com Dave Grimes

    Tim,

    What a terrific reference this is! This spans the majority of online business models, and is a great starting point for anyone in the development phase for their online business.

    Do you have a particular business model you prefer, or perhaps some of these that you think usually fail? If so, why? Thanks.

  • http://FoolishAdventure.com Tim Conley

    I prefer the Country Club model because the value shifts from being in the content to the members interacting with each other. However, each has its place. Simple, old school newsletters aren’t sexy, but they can be profitable especially in niches where specialized knowledge can have high returns or where there are few sources for the info.

  • http://FoolishAdventure.com Tim Conley

    I forgot that there was a bit of code that has to be changed. See this WordPress support forum post: http://wordpress.org/support/topic/teaser-and-password-authentication#post-475733

  • http://FoolishAdventure.com Tim Conley

    There is also a free plugin called Register Plus that can be used to set up a membership site. It has a lot of limitations, but it can be used to set up a site quickly without buying a membership management software.

  • http://learnjapanesepod.com Learn Japanese Pod

    Awesome article and as always an inspiration. I have a question about membership sites. I am a professional guitar teacher and I want to start a a site for studying guitar with a membership area. My question is, would you, or anyone else reading this comment have any advice for trying to differentiate my site from the hundreds of other guitar playing sites out there? I also run a site for Learn Japanese which also seems be less and less unique.

    I have the skills and knowledge but I have a feeling this is quite a crowded market out there for this field. Any thoughts?

  • http://FoolishAdventure.com Tim Conley

    The competition is getting crazy thick in both of those niches. I would recommend doing a product that is a niche within an niche — is there some kind of guitar playing or type of guitar that other training programs aren’t covering?

    Same with Japanese. You may also want to develop a hook like learning in 7 days or play a song in 1 hour or something like that to help you stand out.

  • Scott C

    Hi, I am slowly catching up with all the content, I watched the webinar today on product launch. And have heard all the podcast, I was very inspired when Tim told me I had “massive action” when I got out of bed and started a shopify account a few weeks ago. I am sports guy, I now am an authorized dealer with an equipment company and have two videos I produced. I really did the dealer thing to get more products on my site and offer incentives for my future membership site. I will have my two videos on sale in dvd format soon, plus I want to start a membership site, which I have in the works. I will ask details about that sooner than later, in another message.

    I have a few options: sell my two products, with dvd and direct web-streaming and skip the membership until I get more products or just start the membership for a shorter length of time at low cost and make promises of more content over the next few months. Any other good options or ideas?

    I have interest in how to use sequential content, how is this done and with what program?  Is that how foolish university works? I am signing up for that soon as well.

    If anyone can explain in more detail the sequential content. How is this staggered, does amember do that? I need advice.

    I have my site with weebly and aweber, both are really cool.

    I will probably research it more myself as well.

    Thanks
    Scott  ”massive action” C

  • http://FoolishAdventure.com Tim Conley

    I’m not sure how amember handles sequential/drip content, but you can get a plugin that will manage it if you were on WordPress. Maybe there is something for weebly to help you out.

  • http://learnjapanesepod.com Learn Japanese Pod

    Hi Tim, thanks for that.. I think the niche in the niche and marketing with a hook are some great ideas there. Will, let you know how I get on. Thanks again!